2008-09 Returning Player Roster
| Name | Yr. | Hometown / High School |
| Jason Almendinger | So. | |
| Greg Day | So. | Wayne, Ohio / Elmwood |
| Drew Jackson | Fr. | |
| Brandon Kisseberth | Jr. | Arlington, Ohio / Arlington |
| Zack Koinis | Jr. | Vermilion, Ohio / Vermilion |
| Trenton Kuelling | Jr. | Mansfield, Ohio / Madison |
| Kevin Lenhart | Jr. | Arlington, Ohio / Arlington |
| David Lilly | So. | Greencastle, Ind. / Greencastle |
| Zak Markley | So. | Williamsville, N.Y. / Williamsville South |
| Craig Meyer | Sr. | Norwalk, Ohio / St. Paul |
| T.J. Monachino | So. | Shaker Heights, Ohio / Shaker Heights |
| Cory Pierson | Fr. | |
| Christopher Reece | So. | Columbus, Ohio / Grandview Heights |
| Tony Travagliante | Sr. | Homerville, Ohio / Black River |