| 4th Quarter Play-by-Play |
| Bw | 2-9 | on Heid47 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Bw | 2-9 | on Heid47 | Ryan O'Rourke pass complete to B. Mahaffey for 26 yards to the HEID21, 1ST DOWN BW (Craig Sykes). |
| Bw | 1-10 | on Heid21 | Josiah Holt rush for 4 yards to the HEID17 (Craig Sykes). |
| Bw | 2-6 | on Heid17 | S. Zuluaga rush for 5 yards to the HEID12 (Adam Cepik;Shane Byrne). |
| Bw | 3-1 | on Heid12 | Josiah Holt rush for 8 yards to the HEID4, 1ST DOWN BW (Shane Byrne). |
| Bw | 1-G | on Heid04 | S. Zuluaga rush for no gain to the HEID4 (Mitchell Kelly;Shane Byrne). |
| Bw | 2-G | on Heid04 | Nolan Sordyl rush for 2 yards to the HEID2 (Tim Littles). |
| Bw | 3-G | on Heid02 | Ryan O'Rourke rush for 2 yards to the HEID0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 11:43. |
| | | Chris Mohler kick attempt failed (blocked) (blocked by S. Fejedelem). |
| Baldwin Wallace 34, Heidelberg 28 |
| | Drive: 8 plays, 48 yards, TOP 3:31 |
| | | Chris Mohler kickoff 29 yards to the HEID36, Aaron Kapelka return 1 yards to the HEID37 (Jake Brandy). |
| Heid | 1-10 | on Heid37 | HEIDELBERG drive start at 11:39. |
| Heid | 1-10 | on Heid37 | Bryan Lacey rush for 2 yards to the HEID39 (Tom Goebel). |
| Heid | 2-8 | on Heid39 | Michael Mees pass complete to C.J. Powell for 21 yards to the BW40, 1ST DOWN HEID, out-of-bounds (Tom Goebel). |
| Heid | 1-10 | on Bw40 | Bryan Lacey rush for 15 yards to the BW25, 1ST DOWN HEID, out-of-bounds (Zach Barley). |
| Heid | 1-10 | on Bw25 | Bryan Lacey rush for 2 yards to the BW23 (Joe Fitch). |
| Heid | 2-8 | on Bw23 | Michael Mees pass complete to Derek Hug for 11 yards to the BW12, 1ST DOWN HEID, out-of-bounds (Joe Kasper). |
| Heid | 1-10 | on Bw12 | Bryan Lacey rush for 11 yards to the BW1, 1ST DOWN HEID (Zach Barley). |
| Heid | 1-G | on Bw01 | Michael Mees rush for 1 yard to the BW0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 09:20. |
| | | Dan Kilger kick attempt good. |
| Heidelberg 35, Baldwin Wallace 34 |
| | Drive: 7 plays, 63 yards, TOP 2:19 |
| | | Dan Kilger kickoff 65 yards to the BW0, touchback. |
| Bw | 1-10 | on Bw25 | BALDWIN WALLACE drive start at 09:20. |
| Bw | 1-10 | on Bw25 | S. Zuluaga rush for no gain to the BW25 (Adam Cepik), PENALTY HEID face mask 15 yards to the BW40, 1ST DOWN BW. |
| Bw | 1-10 | on Bw40 | 1st and 10. |
| Bw | 1-10 | on Bw40 | S. Zuluaga rush for no gain to the BW40 (S. Fejedelem;W. Nunnally). |
| Bw | 2-10 | on Bw40 | Josiah Holt rush for 6 yards to the BW46, out-of-bounds (Tim Littles). |
| Bw | 3-4 | on Bw46 | Ryan O'Rourke pass complete to M. McGervey for 9 yards to the HEID45, 1ST DOWN BW (Craig Sykes). |
| Bw | 1-10 | on Heid45 | Josiah Holt rush for 5 yards to the HEID40, out-of-bounds (Tim Littles). |
| Bw | 2-5 | on Heid40 | S. Zuluaga rush for loss of 1 yard to the HEID41 (Shane Byrne), PENALTY HEID face mask 15 yards to the HEID25, 1ST DOWN BW, NO PLAY. |
| Bw | 1-10 | on Heid25 | Ryan O'Rourke pass incomplete to B. Mahaffey (Tim Littles). |
| Bw | 2-10 | on Heid25 | Josiah Holt rush for 4 yards to the HEID21 (Shane Byrne;Tim Littles). |
| Bw | 3-6 | on Heid21 | Josiah Holt rush for 2 yards to the HEID19, out-of-bounds (Mitchell Kelly). |
| Bw | 4-4 | on Heid19 | Ryan O'Rourke pass incomplete to Gabe Adams (Tim Littles). |
| | Drive: 9 plays, 56 yards, TOP 3:33 |
| Heid | 1-10 | on Heid19 | HEIDELBERG drive start at 05:47. |
| Heid | 1-10 | on Heid19 | Bryan Lacey rush for 10 yards to the HEID29, 1ST DOWN HEID (Zach Barley). |
| Heid | 1-10 | on Heid29 | Bryan Lacey rush for 3 yards to the HEID32 (Brandon Russo). |
| Heid | 2-7 | on Heid32 | Dontez Smith rush for 9 yards to the HEID41, 1ST DOWN HEID (Zach Barley). |
| Heid | 1-10 | on Heid41 | Dontez Smith rush for 2 yards to the HEID43 (Alex Risman). |
| Heid | 2-8 | on Heid43 | Bryan Lacey rush for 1 yard to the HEID44 (Reimenschneider). |
| Heid | 3-7 | on Heid44 | Michael Mees pass complete to Derek Hug for 8 yards to the BW48, 1ST DOWN HEID, out-of-bounds. |
| Heid | 1-10 | on Bw48 | Bryan Lacey rush for no gain to the BW48 (Reimenschneider). |
| Heid | 2-10 | on Bw48 | Bryan Lacey rush for 3 yards to the BW45 (Joe Fitch). |
| Heid | 3-7 | on Bw45 | Timeout Baldwin Wallace, clock 02:05. |
| Heid | 3-7 | on Bw45 | Michael Mees pass incomplete to Derek Hug, PENALTY HEID illegal touching declined. |
| Heid | 4-7 | on Bw45 | Colin Bultinck punt 32 yards to the BW13, fair catch by Pat LaGuardia. |
| | Drive: 9 plays, 36 yards, TOP 3:54 |
| Bw | 1-10 | on Bw13 | BALDWIN WALLACE drive start at 01:53. |
| Bw | 1-10 | on Bw13 | Ryan O'Rourke pass complete to B. Mahaffey for 12 yards to the BW25, 1ST DOWN BW, out-of-bounds (Chase Bauer). |
| Bw | 1-10 | on Bw25 | Ryan O'Rourke pass complete to M. McGervey for 15 yards to the BW40, 1ST DOWN BW, out-of-bounds (Tim Littles). |
| Bw | 1-10 | on Bw40 | Ryan O'Rourke pass complete to Pat LaGuardia for 8 yards to the BW48, out-of-bounds (Tim Littles). |
| Bw | 2-2 | on Bw48 | Ryan O'Rourke rush for 7 yards to the HEID45, 1ST DOWN BW (Tim Littles). |
| Bw | 1-10 | on Heid45 | Ryan O'Rourke pass complete to Pat LaGuardia for 8 yards to the HEID37 (Tim Littles). |
| Bw | 2-2 | on Heid37 | Ryan O'Rourke pass incomplete to M. McGervey. |
| Bw | 3-2 | on Heid37 | Timeout Heidelberg, clock 00:40. |
| Bw | 3-2 | on Heid37 | S. Zuluaga rush for 5 yards to the HEID32, 1ST DOWN BW (Adam Cepik). |
| Bw | 1-10 | on Heid32 | Ryan O'Rourke pass incomplete, PENALTY HEID face mask 14 yards to the HEID18, 1ST DOWN BW, NO PLAY. |
| Bw | 1-10 | on Heid18 | Ryan O'Rourke sacked for loss of 2 yards to the HEID20 (Craig Sykes). |
| Bw | 2-12 | on Heid20 | S. Zuluaga rush for 2 yards to the HEID18 (S. Fejedelem). |
| Bw | 3-10 | on Heid18 | Timeout Baldwin Wallace, clock 00:04. |
| Bw | 3-10 | on Heid18 | Chris Mohler field goal attempt from 35 BLOCKED, recovered by HEID Team at HEID0 spot at HEID0, clock 00:00 (blocked by Quentin Rembert), touchback. |
| | Drive: 10 plays, 69 yards, TOP 0:00 |
